Investigation with common sense
Article critical of the bill that expands the Public Prosecution Service's investigative power over authorities and amends the Administrative Improbity Law, 2014.
Translated from the original.
A bill that strengthens the MP to investigate authorities reveals an unsustainable distrust of the Judiciary, as if it were responsible for impunity
A bill is pending in the Senate that greatly strengthens the Public Prosecution Service to investigate authorities and alters the scope of the current Administrative Improbity Law (8,429/92), which turned 22 at the beginning of June. It is Senate Bill (PLS) 286, of 2012, which proposes amendments to the legislation to facilitate the Public Prosecution Service's access to data on the assets and income of persons targeted by this type of investigation.
According to the text, authored by Senator Vital do Rêgo (PMDB-PB), the Public Prosecution Service’s access to such data would be made in real time, allowing prosecutors and federal prosecutors to run queries on the asset evolution and income of the public agents under investigation. The original text required judicial authorization for this measure.
The matter went to the scrutiny of the Senate's Constitution and Justice Committee (CCJ) and has already obtained a favorable opinion from the rapporteur, Senator Pedro Taques (PDT-MT), a former federal prosecutor. In this context, Taques submitted an amendment to the text, allowing the law to provide that the authorization may be obtained through cooperation agreements and conventions to be entered into between the MP and tax administration bodies.
The field of action among institutions therefore increases. Taques also suggested, in his amendment, that access to data be extended as well to spouses, children and other economic dependents of public agents accused of improbity.
According to the latest report of the National Registry of Improbity, maintained by the National Council of Justice (CNJ), almost eight thousand people were convicted in the 22 years the law has been in force. In total, these numbers consisted of 6,578 convictions in actions in the State Courts of Justice and 1,253 in the Federal Regional Courts, since Law 8,429/92 entered into force.
Such convictions include, besides suspension of political rights and loss of public office, payment of R$ 2.11 billion in reimbursement of the damage caused to the public administration, forfeiture of assets and payment of civil fine.
There are no qualitative statistics indicating the types of convictions, much less detailed analyses of the causes of dismissals. It cannot be said, therefore, whether the quantity shown in this database is significant, satisfactory or inadequate in light of Brazil’s reality.
It happens that, by force of the 1988 Constitution, access to fiscal and tax data involving the privacy of the natural or legal person can only occur by court order. Expanding the MP's powers in this realm of the intimate and private life of natural or legal persons requires constitutional reform, which could be done by constitutional amendment.
It does not seem to me reasonable or consistent with the constitutional text to grant the MP, by bill, powers to directly access the bank, tax or fiscal data of persons under investigation. There is no reason whatsoever for Congress to abdicate its powers of constitutional amendment. What would truly be unworkable is to amend the Constitution through a bill, when it is known that the 1988 Constituent Assembly provided for numerous cases of lifting secrecy by court order and guaranteed fundamental rights to privacy, intimacy and the confidentiality of information in the fiscal, tax and banking areas.
This type of bill reveals an untenable distrust of the Judiciary, as if it were responsible for some kind of impunity in the country. Such an insinuation cannot be accepted. Note that the MP has the civil inquiry, a powerful investigative instrument. However, few investigation courses exist in the various Public Prosecution Services of Brazil, and I am not aware that the notices for competitive entrance exams contain subjects related to investigative powers, or the science of investigation. Perhaps this is how any punitive gaps can be explained. It is not for the legislator to change the constitutional environment.
Fabio Medina Osório is a lawyer and president of the International Institute of State Law Studies