Exclusive: ‘The republican principle imposes responsibility on public officials’
Interview on the republican principle and the accountability of public officials, in the context of the defense of former senators in Operation Car Wash (Lava Jato) and of plea bargaining, Correio da Manhã, 2021.
Interview text
Translated from the original.
Former head of the Office of the Attorney General of Brazil, former public prosecutor in Rio Grande do Sul and doctor in administrative law from the Complutense University of Madrid, lawyer Fábio Medina Osório comments, exclusively for Correio da Manhã, on the reasons why his clients, former senators Edson Lobão and Romero Jucá, decided to sue prosecutors from the former Lava Jato task force in Rio, in addition to highlighting some points about the Judiciary’s electronic system.
Cláudio Magnavita: Why did former senators Lobão and Jucá decide to sue the prosecutors of the now-defunct Car Wash (Lava Jato) task force in Rio de Janeiro before the CNMP? What wrongdoing, in your understanding, did they actually commit?
Fábio: My clients are former senators Edison Lobão, Romero Jucá and Márcio Lobão. They were accused in criminal actions that were linked to confidential proceedings. Those proceedings were covered by secrecy by virtue of two judicial decisions: one by Justice Fachin and another by Judge Caroline Figueiredo. The prosecutors knew of those decisions, because they were notified and followed the investigations. When they filed the indictments, they should have preserved the secrecy and reported that secrecy even in e-proc, but they did not. They preferred to disclose the content of confidential information, under the pretext that it was a public criminal action, on the MPF's own website. We understand that at that moment they committed abuse of authority and an administrative infraction. And they should, like any other citizen, answer for their acts, setting an example for society. The immunity of members of the Public Prosecution Service is not something healthy for a democracy. The republican principle demands the accountability of all public agents. This infraction is so serious that it constitutes, at one and the same time, an administrative offense, a criminal offense and administrative improbity. We took the path of the CNMP to obtain an initial response from the State. And, as for the criminal action, my clients managed to have their assets unfrozen, by preliminary injunction, on the grounds, among others, that the prosecutors invoked only the words of informants to obtain the asset freeze. That is, besides leaking confidential information, they also accuse on the basis of nothing but the words of informants.
CM: The prosecutors say that, in reality, they did not breach any secrecy. They claim that the secrecy was assigned automatically by the e-proc system and that this was a determining factor in their mistake, which confused them. Would they have acted in good faith? Is this lawsuit retaliation for the criminal action they brought against your clients?
Bringing criminal actions supported only by the words of informants, without corroborating evidence, is also a form of abuse of power. And it is conduct incompatible with the professionalism expected of experienced members of a Car Wash task force of the Federal Public Prosecution Service. But that is not what is at stake in the Disciplinary Complaint filed with the CNMP. What we are discussing in that body has nothing to do with the merits of the abusive criminal action that was filed, but with the alleged breach of judicial secrecy, an autonomous unlawful act that deserves to be investigated by the competent authority. It seems to me that the prosecutors adopted a defensive strategy of spreading fake news in the media, stating that secrecy had been decreed automatically by e-proc and that this had been decisive for a possible error on their part. That information is false. Even worse, it was reported that the judge had also affirmed that premise. There is no such statement in the case file. Secrecy was decreed, initially, in the investigative record, by judicial decisions. And those decisions were solemnly ignored by the prosecutors when the indictment was filed. In e-proc, when filing the criminal action, the prosecutors reported no secrecy whatsoever, precisely because they disregarded the judicial decisions issued in the proceedings to which the indictment was linked. When the judge accepted the indictment, she merely ratified the secrecy that already existed. That secrecy was later lifted by judicial decision. In other words, it is a simple question: may a member of the Public Prosecution Service, when filing an indictment, disregard secrecy judicially decreed in the investigations? Of course not. And the prosecutors are trying to confuse public opinion with subterfuges and fake news about this Disciplinary Complaint, but at bottom it is very simple.
CM: Do you consider proportionate the request for dismissal filed by the CNMP’s national inspector against the prosecutors upon the opening of the disciplinary proceeding?
First, the STJ established that disciplinary sanctioning power has a discretionary spectrum. Second, the Inspector General set an initial parameter for opening the disciplinary proceeding, which does not mean that this parameter will necessarily be applied by the Collegiate Body at the end of the proceeding, after the exercise of full defense and the adversarial principle, not least because the accused are assured due process and the presumption of innocence, in addition to proportionality and the individualization of sanctions. For these reasons, I think the Inspector General's choice was correct, since if the disciplinary proceeding is accepted he will give the collegiate body a wider range of options. And what is more, it takes into account, in theory, the seriousness of the infraction, which constitutes, as I have already said, also a criminal offense and an act of administrative improbity. The breach of judicial secrecy is a form of ideological corruption: the authority acts in an imperial manner to satisfy its own designs and a peculiar formula of doing justice. It is a serious unlawful act.
CM: What is your expectation regarding the CNMP's judgment on opening this PAD?
The CNMP has been attacked in the media by the prosecutors and by journalists committed to distorting the facts. Regrettably, that is not a good defense strategy. Lying is never a good path. If the prosecutors believe that a criminal action becomes public even when linked to confidential proceedings, and that secrecy may be lifted by the unilateral and sovereign will of the member of the Public Prosecution Service, let them defend that thesis openly. But they must not peddle fake news to public opinion. In our understanding, the disciplinary proceeding should be opened, because a member of the Public Prosecution Service has no prerogative to lift secrecy in a criminal action when it is linked to an investigative proceeding covered by secrecy decreed by judicial decision. The discussion is plain. And the prosecutors insinuated that they have done this before, which is even more serious. Perhaps it will have to be investigated. They circulated a petition against this investigation at the CNMP, but I do not believe it will intimidate the authorities of that body. My conviction is in favor of strengthening the republican institutions and the Brazilian Public Prosecution Service itself. And that comes from controls over eventual abuses and deviations. Note that the prosecutors are also being investigated for allegedly steered plea testimony before the CNMP, in another proceeding. The cleansing of institutions requires an ever stronger CNMP and a responsible and independent Public Prosecution Service.
Article taken from the Correio da Manhã website