Limitation under the new Administrative Improbity Law: retroactive effects
Article on limitation in the new Administrative Improbity Law and its retroactive effects, Conjur, 2021.
Translated from the original.
On the past 25th, federal Law No. 14,230/2021 was published, which brought deep changes to Law 8,429/1992, regulating differently the matter of limitation of the State's sanctioning claim for acts of administrative improbity, in addition to establishing the hypothesis of intercurrent limitation, under article 23 of the General Administrative Improbity Law.
Since the limitation of the sanctioning claim is a matter of substantive law and public order, as the norm itself provides when it says in § 8 of article 23 that it must be recognized and declared even ex officio, it must be recognized that this is a later, more beneficial norm, which must apply retroactively. This is because, under article 5, item XL [1], of the Federal Constitution, criminal guarantees, by symmetry, apply to Administrative Sanctioning Law, as our scholarship has long advocated with regard to improbity actions [2] and in line with the settled case law of the national superior courts [3].
As in the criminal sphere, the limitation of the sanctioning claim in Administrative Sanctioning Law affects the State’s right to punish and is therefore a cause for extinction of punishability, which is why a law regulating limitation periods must apply retroactively when more beneficial, under the constitutional command.
Damásio Evangelista de Jesus is explicit for the case treated here when he gives as an example of a later, more beneficial law that must apply retroactively the one that shortens limitation periods [4] .
The adoption of the constitutional principles of Administrative Sanctioning Law in the sphere of improbity , besides being settled in the case law of the STJ and the STF, was expressly incorporated into the Brazilian legal system by §4 of article 1 of the new wording of the Improbity Law, which on this point embraced our scholarship.
In Disciplinary law, in turn, a subsystem of Administrative Sanctioning Law, as regards limitation and more favorable laws, the STJ has already recognized retroactivity of the more beneficial rule in its case law [5] . There is therefore no doubt that the rule that established a more lenient limitation period, in matters of improbity, must be applied retroactively.
[1] “Article 5 – All are equal before the law, without distinction of any kind, guaranteeing to Brazilians and to foreigners residing in the country the inviolability of the right to life, to liberty, to equality, to security and to property, under the following terms:
XL – criminal law shall not apply retroactively, except to benefit the defendant.”
[2] We have long maintained that Administrative Sanctioning Law governs improbity actions. See the article published in the Revista de Administración Pública (RAP) of Spain 149, in 1999, our pioneering work on this subject, in which we introduced in Brazil a new concept of administrative sanction, which allowed the regime of administrative sanctioning law to be extended to the field of administrative improbity actions. In the first edition of our work Administrative Sanctioning Law, ed. RT, SP, in 2000, we reaffirmed the concept of administrative sanction that allowed its application by the Judiciary, reaching administrative improbity actions, a concept that had an impact on the formation of the convictions of the Higher Courts on this matter. Indeed, the conception reached the understanding of the Higher Courts. The case law of the STJ, in matters of administrative improbity, has been sensitive to the principles of Administrative Sanctioning Law, as seen in numerous STJ judgments, notably this paradigmatic judgment: “Administrative sanctioning law is bound by the principles of legality and typicity, as corollaries of constitutional guarantees”, in which our scholarship is cited: Osório, Fábio Medina. Theory of Administrative Improbity: Public Mismanagement: Corruption: Inefficiency (p. 300). (RESP 87.360-SP, Rapporteur Justice Luiz Fux, judged on 17 June 2008.
[3] Justice Alexandre de Morais expressly admitted the application of administrative sanctioning law in improbity actions in the judgment on admission of general repercussion in extraordinary appeal with interlocutory appeal 1,175,650- Paraná.
[4] Estefam, André; Jesus, Damásio De. Criminal Law 1 – General Part – updated in accordance with Laws 13,869/2019 (Abuse of Authority Law) and 13,964/2019 (Anti-Crime Law) (pp. 148-149). Editora Saraiva. Kindle Edition.
[5] See the following judgments: STJ – AgInt no RMS: 65486 RO 2021/0012771-8, Rapporteur: Justice MAURO CAMPBELL MARQUES, Date of Judgment: 17/08/2021, T2 – SECOND PANEL, Date of Publication: DJe 26/08/2021; RMS 37.031/SP, Rapporteur: Justice REGINA HELENA COSTA, FIRST PANEL, judged on 08/02/2018, DJe 20/02/2018.
Article taken from the website Conjur.com.br